A demon is sent to taunt a man who doesn't believe in him. If touched by the man, the demon falls under his control.
- Phil Fondacaro as the Yattering
- Tony Carbone as Jack Polo
- Thomas Newman as Beelzebub
- Danielle Brisebois as Amanda Polo
- Barbara Shapiro as Caroler
- Paul Sparer as Narrator
- Barbara Shapiro who was a Production Assistant, makes a cameo in this episode one of few where members of the Tales from the Darkside crew make on-screen appearances.